Niners Nation
Walking through the offseason that was in this week’s Reacts Survey.
Welcome to SB Nation Reacts, a survey of fans across the NFL. Throughout the year we ask questions of the most plugged-in San Francisco 49ers fans and fans across the country. Sign up here to participate in the weekly emailed surveys.
It’s been a while since we've had an offseason involving the San Francisco 49ers without a shred of quarterback controversy. Even last year, when it was expected that Brock Purdy would resume as the starter when he returned from his UCL surgery, there were debates about who could hold down the fort better between Sam Darnold and Trey Lance.
The tune is different this offseason. It’s Brock’s job. Still, we knew there would be unexpected moves and roster turnover. That’s how the NFL works. Sure enough, team captain Arik Armstead was released after refusing to take a pay cut.
That meant the 49ers would need to shift their focus to free agency to replace their versatile defensive lineman. The 49ers were never going to replace Armstead in a 1-for-1 move. They chose to go the quantity at defensive tackle by trading for Maliek Collins of the Houston Texans, signing Jordan Elliott from the Cleveland Browns, and rolling the dice on Yetur Gross-Matos from the Carolina Panthers. Those snaps will also go to Javon Kinlaw, who joined Robert Saleh and the New York Jets.
Nick Bosa is still a Defensive Player of the Year candidate. Javon Hargrave was among the best interior rushers in the NFL last season. The 49ers hope those two will do the heavy lifting while the rotational players above stay healthy and the other signing along the defensive line, Leonard Floyd, keeps up his knack for sacks.
The 49ers finished 15th in defensive success rate during the regular season last year. That can’t happen when you have as much talent on this side of the ball as they do. They were in the bottom tier in rushing EPA, and success rate allowed.
Part of that can be pointed to Armstead's inability to stay healthy. San Francisco’s numbers ballooned after Armstead went down after the Eagles game. However, the 49ers suffered an injury in the Super Bowl that could affect them well into the start of 2024.
Linebacker Dre Greenlaw suffered a torn Achilles in the Super Bowl. Greenlaw is the heartbeat of the defense. The Kansas City Chiefs could not move the ball when 57 was on the field. We saw the difference when Dre left the field.
For my money, Greenlaw deserved to be an All-Pro last season. You don’t replace what Greenlaw means to the 49ers. In 2023, Greenlaw had more tackles for loss than missed tackles. He was also tied for fifth among all linebackers in holding penalties drawn. The cherry on top is that Greenlaw made plays at the line of scrimmage against the run. He was in the top ten, tied with Fred Warner, in average tackle depth—and that’s before...
