Why it will take more than just a new defensive coordinator to fix the Cowboys defense

Why it will take more than just a new defensive coordinator to fix the Cowboys defense
Blogging The Boys Blogging The Boys

When you fire your defensive coordinator (or let him walk, or let him go on a sabbatical, or whatever the Cowboys decide to do with Matt Eberflus), it’s often because the entire organization failed, and not just the guy nominally responsible for the defense. It follows that when you’re looking to fix that defense, you’re going to have to look at more than just the coaching. Because if you don’t, you’ll quickly find yourself back in the position you wanted to get out of in the first place.

While saying goodbye to Eberflus is the right decision, the danger is that it provides the Cowboys with a waaaay too convenient excuse for everything that went sideways with the defense this season, and thus provides carte blanche for the Jones family and the front office to continue doing business as usual.

In Dallas, the general thinking heading into 2025 was that changing out the defensive coordinator and getting key players back healthy should be enough to be a Super Bowl contender again – despite not even having sniffed an NFC Championship game in decades. As such, the Cowboys front office was perfectly content to think that

  • a defense that ranked 28th in defensive passer rating and 31st in points allowed just needed some Matt Eberflus fairy dust to become a Top 10 unit.
  • a defensive line that ranked 28th in rushing yards per attempt just needed to invest in some over-the-hill free agent defensive tackles and the Cowboys would be a lock for the next NFC Championship game.
  • in a league that’s all about the pass, trading away a generational pass rush talent for some run stuffers and picks was a brilliant idea.
  • a pro scouting department that in 2024 brought in Ezekiel Elliott and Dalvin Cook to help out in the running game, traded a fourth for Jonathan Mingo, and has an increasingly spotty draft record should continue acquiring talent in 2025 without changing their way of working.
  • an organization that thinks it went “all-in” in 2024 and ended up at 7-10 can continue doing business as usual and doesn’t really need to change much.

The odds were stacked against ‘Flus from day one. It’s convenient to think that his scheme is the root cause of it all, but this is a complete organizational failure that goes way beyond just the DC, and it looks like even Jerry Jones is beginning to realize that.

Will the Cowboys get it right this time? I wouldn’t bet on it, but it’s not impossible. Three teams very recently demonstrated what it takes to turn around a bottom 10 defense into a top 10 unit – in just one year.

  • 2023 Detroit Lions: From 2023 to 2024, the Lions improved their defensive passer rating (DPR) from 91.5 to 82, climbing from 20th to 1st in the league – in just one year.
  • 2023 Philadelphia Eagles: From 2023 to 2024, Philly improved their DPR by an impressive 15.1...