Vikings Bye Week Decisions: Wentz or McCarthy?

In this episode, Darren Campbell and Dave Stefano unpack the Minnesota Vikings’ bye week challenges, focusing on quarterback decisions, offensive adaptations, and team updates. With the team at 3-2 after a 2-1 run under Carson Wentz, the hosts analyze if head coach Kevin O’Connell should stick with the veteran or revert to J.J. McCarthy for long-term growth. They highlight Wentz’s solid stats like a 69% completion rate and 99.5 passer rating, contrasted by concerns such as a 41.5 QBR and high sack rate. Transitioning to offense, they praise O’Connell’s shift to quicker passes, evidenced by Wentz’s 2.43-second release against Cleveland, which neutralized threats like Myles Garrett. However, they note persistent issues like third-down woes (31% conversion) and low scoring (21 points in two starts). The discussion also covers Vikingsland news, resolving Christian Darrisaw’s snap count mystery as conditioning-related, questioning Jordan Addison’s reliability post-benching, defending Dallas Turner’s slow sack start amid coverage duties, and explaining the team’s 50.8% roster retention—the lowest among 2024 playoff teams—as strategic despite the slower start.

• QB Quandary Deep Dive: Wentz’s 2-1 record impresses, but stats show duality—top-10 in yards per attempt yet 26th in QBR; hosts argue McCarthy needs reps for development, quoting Alex Boone: “The starter isn’t Josh Allen or Pat Mahomes.”
• Offensive Evolution Under O’Connell: Shift to short passes (22 of 34 under 15 yards vs. Browns) addresses line injuries (Kelly out 3+ games, O’Neill timeline unclear); however, it risks longer drives and errors, potentially sacrificing EPA for protection.
• Darrisaw’s Snap Mystery Solved: Initial “pitch count” explanation doubted, but ESPN confirms self-removal for post-surgery conditioning; positive injury news amid line woes.
• Addison’s Availability Concerns: Benching after missing walkthrough post-suspension raises professionalism questions; Campbell notes, “The most important ability is availability,” impacting extension talks.
• Turner’s Progress Amid Hype: One sack despite 241 snaps; Flores’ 32.5% coverage drops limit rushes compared to Greenard’s 18%; hosts urge patience, citing Van Ginkel and Greenard’s slow starts.
• Roster Turnover Analysis: 50.8% retention ties for third-lowest, behind only rebuilding teams; moves from Gilmore, Darnold, etc., deemed logical for upgrades, though Phillips trade questioned for run defense impact.

Listen:

Watch:

As the Vikings eye a rebound against the Eagles post-bye, this episode reminds fans that patience and bold decisions could turn a transitional season into something special. Don’t miss Campbell and Stefano’s raw, insightful banter—tune into Two Old Bloggers on Vikings 1st & SKOL for more episodes that cut through the noise and fuel your Purple passion. Subscribe now and join the conversation!

Fan With Us!

We have your Minnesota Vikings talk amongst the Two Old Bloggers, Darren @KickassblogVike, and Dave @Luft_Krigare along with our numbers guy, Drew Bunting. Join the conversation! Fan with us at Vikings 1st & SKOL @Vikings1stSKOL and with our podcast partner Fans First Sports Network @FansFirstSN and the network’s NFL feed over at Pro Football Insiders @Pro_FB_Insiders. Your ultimate source for NFL insights, breaking news, and expert analysis. From draft prospects to game-day strategies, we’ve got the...