Super Bowl 2025 best bets: Leaning hard into Eagles' underdog status vs. Chiefs

Super Bowl 2025 best bets: Leaning hard into Eagles' underdog status vs. Chiefs
For The Win For The Win

It’s here. After 284 games, this year’s NFL season is finally at its terminus. Either the Philadelphia Eagles or Kansas City Chiefs will be bathed in confetti at the end of the 2025 Super Bowl, ready to celebrate into the morning hours in New Orleans.

While the betting public is high on a Kansas City three-peat, our resident betting expert, the Rhode Island Scumbag, is fading the trends. And you know what? I’m with him.

Let’s get right into it. Scumbag analysis and plays are in blockquotes below. My non-Scumbag bets follow.

We have arrived at the culmination of the NFL season, hungry to turn a profit after a rough go in the championship round. I’m looking to make contrarian plays to try and avoid going with the crowd and rooting for the sportsbooks to turn a profit.

I leaned too hard in the other direction in the last round, and paid dearly for it. At the risk of being in complete harmony with Christian’s picks, here are a couple wagers I like for the Big Game ™.

Scumbag Play No. 1: Philadelphia Eagles moneyline winners over the Kansas City Chiefs (-105)

Here is my thought process. My sportsbook is currently offering Philadelphia at +1 but at -115 odds. Since the outcome won’t end up in a tie regardless, the one point advantage doesn’t do much for me. I’d rather take the improved odds on the moneyline and hope for the best.

Ultimately, I think that Philadelphia has the defensive prowess and offensive weapons to not only keep up with, but flat out beat Kansas City and prevent their three-peat from becoming a reality.

Scumbag play No. 2: 2025 Super Bowl total UNDER 49.5

In terms of the under, I can still get it at 49.5, even though I’ve seen it drop to 48.5 on many of the betting sites. The public seems to really like taking the over here, leading me to lean towards the under. A 27-21 final score is completely in the realm of possibility and with both defenses playing well, I am comfortable with this wager.

Bonus prop bets!

Here are a few bonus scoring props with some decent odds that I can also get behind:

  • Pat Mahomes anytime touchdown (+360)
  • A.J. Brown anytime touchdown (+166)
  • First position to score a touchdown: Quarterback/TE (both +420)

Last week: 0-2, -2 units
Regular season: 35-26-1 (.574), +9 units
Playoffs: 4-4-1 (.500), +0 units

My non-Scumbag pick: Eagles alt line -2.5 over the Chiefs (one unit to win 1.5)

I don’t love the payout here; I thought a four-point swing would get me closer to a +200 reward. But that would take a 5.5-point spread to get there and that’s too risky a line against Patrick Mahomes and his endless string of postseason magic.

So why do the Eagles win when Kansas City keeps finding ways to escape close games? Allow me to plagiarize myself....