Potential Cap Casualties 2026: The case for and against Rashan Gary

Potential Cap Casualties 2026: The case for and against Rashan Gary
Acme Packing Company Acme Packing Company

A week ago,t he Packers were in the playoffs. Today, their attention is on the 2026 season.

Who’s going to be a part of that 2026 team? Not everyone from 2025 can or will come back, and a few of the Packers’ biggest names are in the danger zone due to their high cap numbers for next season. Over the next week or so, I’m going to take a look at a few of the potential cap casualties in Green Bay, starting with edge rusher Rashan Gary.

The Packers selected Rashan Gary with the 12th overall pick in the 2019 NFL Draft, stashing him behind newly acquired free agents Za’Darius Smith and Preston Smith as the world’s most highly drafted developmental prospect.

The Packers’ patience eventually paid off, as Gary blossomed into a productive and reliable pass rusher. By 2022, he was the team’s unquestioned top edge, and looked poised for a long and productive career. But he tore his ACL midway through the 2022 season, and although he came back strong at the start of 2023, on balance he has never really been the same post-injury. Nevertheless, he signed a lucrative extension in 2023, and his cap hit for 2026 stands at just over $28 million.

Will he be back with the Packers in 2026? Here’s the case for and against Rashan Gary.

The case for Rashan Gary

The best argument for Gary comes down to counting stats, both traditional and semi-advanced. A look at the raw numbers suggests a player that was doing the work in 2025.

Gary logged 7.5 sacks, tied for the third-highest mark of his career and equal to the total that got him to the Pro Bowl in 2024. His 20 quarterback hits were also the third-highest mark of his career.

Gary was also solid in the run game. Previously, that had been a weakness in his game, but he’s fashioned it into something resembling a strength over the past few seasons. According to Pro Football Focus, Gary recorded 17 “stops” in run defense in 2025 (a stop being the defensive counterpart to offensive success rate, explained here; when a player prevents the offense from running an analytically “successful” play, he gets credit for a stop), third best among defensive lineman or edge rushers on the Packers behind Colby Wooden (23 stops) and Kingsley Enagbare (18).

Essentially, from a raw numbers perspective, Gary is doing the work. Maybe it’s not quite at the level of production you’d like from a player getting paid like he is, but his numbers are at least respectable.

The case against Rashan Gary

Or are they? At a surface level, Gary’s production looks good, though certainly not great. But digging beyond just the very most basic level, you’ll see the statistical profile of a player in decline.

For starters, although Gary recorded 7.5 sacks in 2025, he finished the season on a two-month sackless streak. He sacked Aaron Rodgers twice just before Halloween, but it was goose eggs from...