NFL Draft: Round 1 College Playoff Discussion Thread

NFL Draft: Round 1 College Playoff Discussion Thread
Acme Packing Company Acme Packing Company

The college football playoff kicks off on Friday, so it’s time to break down who the top draft prospects are in these games. As always, the rankings come from the consensus draft board. Juniors will have one asterisk next to their name, while draft-eligible sophomores will have two.

Come hang out with us during the action and share your thoughts on the games.

College Football Playoff Games

Alabama @ Oklahoma

  • Friday, December 19th (7 pm CT, ABC/ESPN)
  • Alabama
    • #7 QB Ty Simpson*
    • #19 OT Kadyn Proctor*
    • #37 ED L.T. Overton
    • #63 WR Germie Bernard
    • #79 LB Deontae Lawson
    • #116 CB Domani Jackson
    • #129 iOL Parker Brailsford*
    • #148 S Keon Sabb*
    • #164 S Bray Hubbard*
    • #182 iDL Tim Keenan III
    • #189 TE Josh Cuevas
    • #190 iOL Jaeden Roberts
    • #192 RB Jamarion Miller
  • Oklahoma
    • #49 ED R Mason Thomas
    • #110 QB John Mateer*
    • #136 WR Deion Burks
    • #170 iDL Gracen Halton

Alabama clearly has the talent advantage in the first playoff game, but the Crimson Tide has really struggled to run the football all season, and Oklahoma has had the edge over them recently. Earlier in 2025, Oklahoma gave Alabama the Crimson Tide their only regular-season SEC loss of the year. The Sooners also beat them 24-3 in 2024, too.

This year, Alabama only rushed for 3.6 yards per attempt, which is the second-worst number in the SEC. Against Georgia, they carried the ball 16 times for -3 yards.

The winner of this game will play Indiana in the Rose Bowl.

Miami @ Texas A&M

  • Saturday, December 20th (11 am CT, ABC/ESPN)
  • Miami
    • #4 ED Rueben Bain*
    • #11 OT Francis Mauigoa*
    • #65 ED Akheem Mesidor
    • #120 QB Carson Beck
    • #158 WR C.J. Daniels
    • #171 CB Keionte Scott
  • Texas A&M
    • #26 ED Cashius Howell
    • #29 WR Kevin Concepcion*
    • #42 S Dalton Brooks*
    • #72 iOL Chase Bisontis*
    • #83 CB Will Lee III
    • #92 LB Taurean York*
    • #163 OT Dametrious Crownover
    • #223 RB Le’Veon Moss
    • #228 OT Trey Zuhn III

All four of Miami’s draftable seniors this year are sixth-year players, so they’re older than you’d expect. Edge rusher Akheem Mesidor, notably, will be 25 years old on draft day after spending two years at West Virginia and four more with the Hurricanes.

As far as players from The U are concerned, Packers fans might want to keep tabs on quarterback Carson Beck. This quarterback class isn’t going to be very deep, but Green Bay is going to need to come out of this draft with a backup behind Jordan Love. I wouldn’t be surprised if the team spent a third- or fourth-round pick at the position. The Georgia transfer is at least someone who will be in the conversation.

For an A&M player, look at left tackle Trey Zuhn III, who was given...