Daily Norseman
He has spent a year learning the offense!
I am a firm believer in giving a young QB at least two years of starts (I would do three years if I am running things) before attempting to make a decision on their long term prospects with the team. Young QBs need time and will make mistakes like all QBs do. Patience is the key. The hopes are obviously very high but they cannot overtake common sense.
...
I asked google “how many years should an nfl team give a rookie quarterback before moving on” and here is the AI Mode response ...
In the NFL, the question of how long to give a rookie quarterback before moving on is a complex one, as there’s no single “correct” answer. It depends heavily on individual circumstances and the needs of the team.
Factors influencing the decision:
Talent and Development: Some rookies demonstrate the ability to lead a team quickly, while others need more time to learn and adjust to the NFL’s speed and complexity.
Team Situation:
Need at the position: If a team has a pressing need for a starting QB, they may be forced to play a rookie sooner.
Veteran mentorship: A strong veteran QB on the roster can provide invaluable guidance and allow a rookie to develop at a more measured pace.
Overall team strength: A strong supporting cast (offensive line, receivers, etc.) can help a rookie succeed even if they are still developing.
Coaching and Strategy: A capable coaching staff can implement schemes that help a rookie QB succeed and provide the necessary support for their development.
Contract Situation: First-round rookie contracts are typically four years with a fifth-year option, providing a defined window for evaluation.
Patience and Evaluation: Teams need to be patient, especially with highly-drafted rookies, but also realistic about whether a player is demonstrating enough growth to be the long-term solution.
Common approaches and timelines:
Year 1-2: Some teams may start their rookie QB right away, even if it means weathering some growing pains. Others opt to sit them behind a veteran, allowing them to learn without the pressure of being the immediate starter.
Year 3-4: By this point, teams generally have a good idea of a QB’s potential and whether they should be considered the franchise player. It’s crucial to evaluate their progress and decide whether to exercise the fifth-year option or consider other options.
Beyond Year 4: If a QB hasn’t shown the necessary improvement or consistency by the end of their rookie contract, the team may look to move on.
In summary: There’s no set rule for how long a team should give a rookie QB. It’s a strategic decision based on the player’s potential, the team’s needs, and the overall context of the situation. While patience is important, teams also need to be realistic about when to make a change.
Former Vikings QB Daunte Culpepper says J.J. McCarthy will be “a master”
*Daunte Culpepper recently sat down with WCCO’s Mike Max...
