5 Questions with Cat Scratch Reader: What we learned about the Panthers

5 Questions with Cat Scratch Reader: What we learned about the Panthers
Big Cat Country Big Cat Country

As the Jacksonville Jaguars prepare to play the Carolina Panthers in Week 1, we sat down with Walker Clement of Cat Scratch Reader to learn more about the opposing side.

Question 1: What does a successful 2025 season look like for the Panthers, and how much of it has to do with quarterback Bryce Young?

A lot of fans have said six wins would be a successful season. That’s a step up from last year and more than we’ve seen from a full-time head coach since 2018. I don’t think that’s enough. We’re tired of losing and I think 11 losses would be too heavy. Seven to nine wins, Young continuing on his progress at the end of last season, and more competitive losses than blowouts are the bar for a successful season. An opening day win wouldn’t hurt, either.

Question 2: Carolina got a fourth-round pick by trading 35-year-old Adam Thielen to Minnesota. It’s a clear on-paper win, but was it worth losing Young’s most trusted target?

It’s a harder trade to judge now that we lost his second-most reliable target, second year receiver Jalen Coker, to a quad injury for 4-6 weeks. Long story short, we’re going to have to see how Xavier Legette, Tetairoa McMillan, and Hunter Renfrow step up. They’re all either young, new to the team, or both. There’s a lot of chemistry there that we haven’t really seen on the field, good or bad.

Long story long, the last time the Panthers opened at Jacksonville, in 2015, they went to the Super Bowl. Cam Newton lost his leading receiver and favorite target from 2014, Kelvin Benjamin, right before the start of the season. He leveled up and dragged a corps of no-name receivers and an aged Jerricho Cotchery to a dominant 15-1 regular season record. Once is history, but if Young can do it again then it becomes a tradition. These are the kinds of realistic expectations that we’re placing on the shoulders of our quarterback.

Question 3: How concerning are the injuries to WR Jalen Coker (on injured reserve) and OT Ikem Ekwonu (in danger of missing Week 1)?

Coker is on IR, as linked above, and will miss a minimum of four weeks. Ekwonu is a bigger question. He hasn’t practiced this week (as of Wednesday) and is not yet two weeks removed from an emergency appendectomy. Even laparoscopically, that’s still major abdominal surgery with risks of complications (and further time lost) if he rushes back to the field. My expectation is that we’ll see Brady Christensen, an extremely capable backup, fill in at left tackle. Yosh Nijman, also a capable backup, is the other option. You can read more on the decision the Panthers may have to make at left tackle here.

Question 4: Who’s an under-the-radar player that Jaguars fans should watch out for in this game?

It’s weird to call a Pro Bowl player “under-the-radar” but I have to go with Derrick Brown...