5 biggest surprises from 53-man roster cuts, Aidan O’Connell keeps his spot

5 biggest surprises from 53-man roster cuts, Aidan O’Connell keeps his spot
Silver And Black Pride Silver And Black Pride

The NFL’s cutdown day has come and gone, meaning the Las Vegas Raiders have their initial 53-man roster set. There are a few surprises every year, so let’s dive into the five biggest ones from this past Tuesday.

Aidan O’Connell makes it

The league changed its rules where up to two players can be placed on injured reserve during cutdown day and designated to return, meaning they don’t count against the 53-man roster but don’t have to sit out for the entire season, missing at least four regular-season games instead.

With O’Connell suffering a fractured wrist in the final preseason game and expected to be out for six to eight weeks, it seemed like a foregone conclusion that he’d receive this designation. On top of that, he had four turnovers during the preseason, and the Raiders traded a fifth-round pick for Kenny Pickett on Monday. However, O’Connell made the team and occupied one of the 53 roster spots while rookie Cam Miller was cut.

So, instead of taking advantage of the new rule—which Las Vegas did with safety Lonnie Johnson Jr.—the offense has two backup quarterbacks on the roster and neither is a long-term starting option. Pickett is on the last year of his rookie contract while O’Connell has two years left, and Geno Smith is signed through 2027. That makes this move a bit of a head-scratcher.

To be fair, Miller did clear waivers and is coming back to Vegas on the practice squad, per Silver and Black Pride’s Tristen Kuhn.

Tommy Mellott gets cut

Don’t get it twisted, Mellott didn’t show anything as a wide receiver during the preseason, catching two passes for one yard in three games. But the organization knew he was going to take some time to develop when it drafted the former FCS quarterback and asked him to switch positions while making a major jump in the level of competition. Also, part of the reason he was drafted was his ability to contribute on special teams.

Instead, the Raiders opted to keep four receivers and sign Amari Cooper off the street to round out the position group. Again, this isn’t to say that Mellott was expected to play a significant role on the team this year. However, it was surprising to see the sixth-round pick get left off the roster given the circumstances.

This could have been a situation where the rookie and running back Dylan Laube were competing for a roster spot via a role on special teams, and Laube won that job. Mellott was also not listed when the Raiders announced their practice squad.

10 offensive linemen

Most teams only roster nine offensive linemen and dress eight on gameday, so Las Vegas will be one of the few clubs to keep 10 guys in the trenches. The surprise here is that Will Putnam made the team. Putnam received some hype during last year’s training camp but was pretty quiet this summer, and posted a slightly above-average 63.6 grade from...