2026 Draft: The Steelers QB Dating Game — Series wrap

2026 Draft: The Steelers QB Dating Game — Series wrap
Behind the Steel Curtain Behind the Steel Curtain

Congratulations, Steelers fans and BTSC readers, we’ve made it through the long summer between the NFL Draft and the return of actual football. I know that this website is primarily focused on the Steelers and the NFL, but it’s been a ton of fun reviewing college quarterbacks with you these past few months.

Below, you’ll find the winner from our Final Round of Five fan vote, but first, let’s set the table for the weekend ahead of us.

Week 1 of the NFL season is still a week away, but college football has already begun. After a handful of games were played last weekend, the season will kick off in earnest this week. All 15 of the quarterbacks featured in this series will see their first action of 2025.

Better still, three of our finalists will undertake marquee matchups against ranked opponents. That includes the highlight of the week: Garrett Nussmeier and Cade Klubnik squaring off head-to-head. And of course, Arch Manning is facing his first real challenge as Texas’ QB1 right out of the gate.

CFB Week 1 games featuring our QB Dating Game contestants:

  • Friday, August 29 — Western Michigan @ Michigan St. (Aidan Chiles)
  • Friday, August 29 — Auburn @ Baylor (Sawyer Robertson)
  • Saturday, August 30 — (1) Texas (Arch Manning) @ (3) Ohio St.
  • Saturday, August 30 — Old Dominion @ (20) Indiana (Fernando Mendoza)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Nevada @ (2) Penn St. (Drew Allar)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Montana St. @ (7) Oregon (Dante Moore)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Alabama A&M @ Arkansas (Taylen Green)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Illinois St. & (18)Oklahoma (John Mateer)
  • Saturday, August 30 — (9) LSU (Garrett Nussmeier) @ (4) Clemson (Cade Klubnik)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Missouri St. @ USC (Jayden Maiava)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Northern Arizona @ (11) Arizona St. (Sam Leavitt)
  • Saturday, August 30 — Utah @ UCLA (Nico Iamaleava)
  • Sunday, August 31 — Virginia Tech @ (13) South Carolina (LaNorris Sellers)
  • Sunday, August 31 — (6) Notre Dame @ (10) Miami (Carson Beck)
    Denotes Final Round of Five Finalist

And now our winner…

The race was tight from start to finish. After collecting a cumulative 802 votes for the entire first round, y’all nearly halved that with 304 votes in our Final Round of Five. Four of the five finalists led the vote at some point during the polling process, demonstrating that QB1 is still very much up for grabs roughly eight months from the 2026 NFL Draft.

But in the end, much like Highlander, there can be only one.

As a reminder, we used a ranked choice voting system to determine our winner. Voters were asked to tell us which quarterback they’d most like to see the Steelers draft by ranking our five finalists. First-place votes were awarded five points, second-place votes four points, and so on. This was done in an effort to form a...