2025 NFC West: Offensive Line Comparisons

How does the Cardinals’ offensive line stack up against their division rivals?

As is a yearly tradition here at ROTB, we compare the Cardinals’ projected starters on the offensive line to those of the Rams. 49ers and Seahawks. Typically, heading into training camp the Cardinals’ offensive line has gotten little love from NFL pundits.

This year —- there has been a change in point of view, according to 10-year NFL scout, Scott Barrett!

Ranking All 32 Offensive Lines in the NFL

2025 NFC West Projected Offensive Line Starters:

LT:

1. SFO —- Trent Williams —- 85.6* (10 games started in 2024)
2. SEA —- Charles Cross —- 82.5
3. ARI —- Paris Johnson Jr. —- 80.8
4. LAR —- D.J. Humphries —- 44.8* (UFA 2025, Joe Noteboom left in FA, Alaric Jackson on IR)

LG:

1. LAR —- Steve Avila —- 66.1
2. ARI —- Evan Brown —- 65.9
3. SFO —- Ben Bartch —- (74.8 in 3 games for SFO in 2024)
4. SEA —- Grey Zabel —- R

C:

1. ARI —- Hjalte Froholdt —- 76.1
2. LAR —- Coleman Shelton —- 66.4* (UFA 2025 CHI)
3. SFO —- Jake Brendal —- 65.0
4. SEA —- Olu Oluwatami —- 64.2

RG:

1. SFO —- Dominick Puni —- 80.5
2. LAR —- Kevin Dotson —- 78.2
3. ARI —- Isaiah Adams —- 58.4
4. SEA —- Christian Haynes —- 48.5

RT:

1. LAR —- Rob Havenstein —- 75.8
2. SFO —- Colton McKivitz —- 72.2
3. ARI —- Jonah Williams —- 70.7* (6 games in 2024)
4. SEA —- Abraham Lucas —- 61.9 (7 games in 2024)

2024 Run Blocking NFC West Rankings:

1. SFO—- #3
2. LAR —- #6
3. ARI —- #14
4. SEA —- #24

2024 Pass Blocking NFC West Rankings:

1. ARI —- #4
2. SFO —- #11
3. SEA —- #26
4. LAR —- #30

2024 Offense NFC West Rankings:

1. SFO —- #5
2. ARI —- #7
3. LAR —- #9
4. SEA —- #16

2024 Passing Offense NFC West Rankings:

1. SEA —- #7
2. ARI —- #8
3. LAR —- #19
4. SFO —- #20

2024 Rushing Offense NFC West Rankings:

1. SEA —- #6
2. ARI —- #9
3. SFO —- #13
4. LAR —- #22

2024 Offensive DVOA NFC West Rankings:

1. LAR —- #9
2. ARI —- #12
3. SFO —- #14
4. SEA —- #18

2025 Continuity —- combined 2024 starts for returning starters:

1. ARI —- 65
2. SFO —- 54
3. SEA —- 41
4. LAR —- 40

Total Points:

1. ARI —- 35
2. SFO —- 34
3. LAR —- 28
4. SEA —- 22

Scott DiBenedetto’s 2025 NFL Offensive Line Rankings

2025 NFL Offensive Line Rankings | Fantasy Points

What makes a good offensive line?

Scott’s criteria with my 2025 grades for Cardinals:

• Continuity — I can’t stress enough how important continuity is for an offensive line. Yes, teams have seen quick improvements after bringing in a new...